Roofs & Slates
Drumlin Country Roofs: Why the Back Plane Greens FirstIn Cavan and Monaghan a house built into a drumlin often has one roof plane that barely sees winter sun. That is the side that goes green. ...
Roofs & Slates
Key takeaways
The quote form on our roof cleaning in Longford page asks for your roof type, and one of the options is “Not sure”. It is a fair answer: from a garden or a footpath, a concrete tile can pass for clay, a fibre cement slate can pass for natural slate, and a roof that has gone green or black can hide what it is made of altogether. Here are the visible differences, and why the answer comes first.
The first stage of every roof visit is an assessment of the tile type, its condition, the pitch and the access. Tile type leads that list for a reason.
Every roof, whatever it is made of, finishes the same way: a biocide applied at low pressure across the whole plane after the moss comes off. What changes from one covering to the next is how the loose growth is removed before that: scraped, pressure washed or cleared by hand, according to what that tile can take.
The Government of Ireland’s guide to repairing historic roofs records concrete tiles being made by Irish manufacturers from the 1930s and becoming prominent on local authority housing. It describes them as interlocking, with a standard size of 380 by 230 mm, which makes them a good deal larger than a traditional clay plain tile. The variety of finishes is the catch. Marley, one of the large tile manufacturers, notes in its guide to clay and concrete tiles that there are “many concrete options that replicate the look of clay”, and others that “give the appearance of natural slate.”
The same guide gives one clue that belongs to concrete alone. Some concrete tiles develop lime bloom, pale patches or streaks caused by natural lime in the concrete reacting with air and rainwater. Marley says it usually washes off within a few months. How concrete tile changes over decades is a subject for another post.
The historic roofs guide describes two traditional clay forms: plain tiles, which are small and flat, and pantiles, which have a double-curved “S” profile. It also notes clay coming back into use on late-Victorian and Edwardian houses in the suburbs of Dublin and Cork. Handmade clay in particular has, in Marley’s words, “natural irregularities that give a unique character to the property”, so a clay roof tends to look slightly uneven in colour and line where a concrete roof looks regular. Since concrete can be made to replicate clay, though, colour alone does not settle it.
SSQ, a natural slate supplier, puts the difference this way in its comparison of natural and fibre cement slate: natural slate “retains its colour, grain and texture because these characteristics are inherent to the stone.” Look for slight variation in colour and surface from one slate to the next. Older slate roofs on period houses have their own cleaning concerns, which a separate post on natural slate roofs covers.
Fibre cement slate is easily taken for natural slate. The tell is uniformity. SSQ notes that fibre cement relies on “coatings, pigments and precision processes to achieve a uniform appearance”, and that its edges and surfaces may show a uniformity that natural slate lacks. The historic roofs guide describes the “generally bland, smooth surface” of fibre cement and notes that its colour can fade in a relatively short time compared with natural slate.
Tegral is the best-known name for it in Ireland, and why it needs gentler handling than tile is set out in our post on Tegral and fibre cement slates.
The moss looks the same on every roof. What is underneath it is the part that decides the job.
Flat roofs, for example over an extension, are on the list too and are a different category: a continuous surface rather than overlapping units. They go through the same assessment as every other roof before anything is quoted.
Without climbing anything, a few things narrow it down:
None of that is a substitute for someone looking properly. The roof pages say it directly: “Not sure what you’re looking at? Send a photograph with your enquiry and we’ll identify it before quoting.”
Shape helps: clay pantiles have a pronounced “S” curve and plain clay tiles are small and flat, while concrete tiles are larger interlocking units. But many concrete tiles are made to look like clay, so a close photograph is more reliable than colour seen from the ground.
Often lime bloom. Marley describes it as pale patches or streaks caused by natural lime in the concrete reacting with air and rainwater, and says it usually washes off within a few months. It is not growth.
Yes. The covering decides how the loose moss can be removed: scraped, pressure washed or cleared by hand. Every roof is then biocided at low pressure across the whole plane.
A clear picture of the roof slope, ideally with a few tiles or slates close enough to see their edges and surface.
Keep reading
Roofs & Slates
Drumlin Country Roofs: Why the Back Plane Greens FirstIn Cavan and Monaghan a house built into a drumlin often has one roof plane that barely sees winter sun. That is the side that goes green. ...
Roofs & Slates
Concrete Roof Tiles on Commuter Estates: How They Age, and When to CleanConcrete tile covers most Kildare and Meath estates. How its face weathers and roughens, why that holds moss, and why the tile still sets th...
Roofs & Slates
Tegral & Fibre-Cement Slates: Why They Need Different TreatmentFibre cement slate is not concrete tile and should not be cleaned like it. How it ages, why the surface is the vulnerable part, and when the...
Not sure what your property needs?
If the growth on your roof or render is doing damage, we will say so. If it can wait, we will say that too.
Get a free quote